Case study · 2023 · filed 24 September 2026

Parents deleted their children's Alexa recordings. The transcripts stayed.

In 2023 the FTC and the US Justice Department charged that Amazon kept children's voice recordings indefinitely and undermined parents' deletion requests. Amazon agreed to a $25 million penalty.

On 31 May 2023 the US Federal Trade Commission and the Justice Department charged Amazon with breaking the US children's privacy law over its Alexa voice assistant.

According to the complaint, Amazon kept children's voice recordings indefinitely and undermined parents' requests to delete them. When a parent deleted the audio, Amazon "failed to delete transcripts of what kids said from all its databases". It used the data to improve its algorithm.

The FTC's Samuel Levine said Amazon's history of "keeping children's recordings indefinitely, and flouting parents' deletion requests violated COPPA and sacrificed privacy for profits." Amazon agreed to a $25 million civil penalty.

What it shows

Pressing delete in an app deletes what the app shows you. Copies elsewhere, like transcripts, logs and training data, can stay behind. A deletion is the company's claim until something proves it.

For your own record

Send the deletion request in writing, name the copies you want gone (recordings, transcripts, anything derived from them), and keep the date and the reply. That dated request is what a regulator measures a company against.

More case studies

Amazon He asked Amazon for his data and was sent a stranger's 1,700 recordings A German customer made an access request in 2018. The link Amazon sent him held 1,700 voice recordings from someone else's home.
Ashley Madison Ashley Madison charged people to be deleted, and kept the rest The affair site charged a fee for a full delete and kept deactivated accounts indefinitely. Then it was breached, and 36 million accounts were exposed.
Muslim Pro A prayer app sent users' locations to a broker that sold to military contractors Muslim Pro uses your location to set prayer times and the direction of Mecca. In 2020 it was also sending that location to a data broker whose customers included US defence contractors.